Need help deciding on artwork

[stephenp1983]

Hey guys its been forever since I've posted here, but I have been lurking around still . Anyway I am about to get started on a second project that will only be a control panel. It will be made by Timoe over at byoac forums that built my street fighter one. This is going to be for my dad for his birthday next year. He loves frogger and all the old school games, so I thought I'd give him a controller so he could enjoy it again. Like I mentioned before it will be a controller only, and sit on the coffee table where it hooks into a pc by the big screen. Just something simple for him to use whenever.

So I have come up with two designs and I need yall opinions on them. If you have a login please go to my thread at byoac place a vote and make a comment about it. If not please feel free to commit here as well. I need to decide which of the two control panel artwork you think looks best.

Thanks,

Stephen

Here is the thread and the images for those that don't want to go to another forum:

http://forum.arcadecontrols.com/index.php?topic=66150.0

Option 1

Option 2

[Adultery]

I like Option 1 the best. It appears more authentic to me for whatever reason.

Just an opinion.

[stephenp1983]

Thanks I believe it is my favorite too, I just hope the green trackball matches it well. No one seems to have a green trackball in their control panel for reference

[Stu1983]

Option 1's got my vote too... no real reason why though... I think your dad would be pleased with either

Stu

[hansolo77]

I don't quite understand the reasoning for the difference. I mean, the only difference is the frog or not the frog in the tire treads... Of course I would go with the first one too.

[stephenp1983]

I don't quite understand the reasoning for the difference. I mean, the only difference is the frog or not the frog in the tire treads... Of course I would go with the first one too.

the difference is that one is with a black trackball to match the the black treads. The other is a green trackball with the frog vector's legs attacked to it.